‘We’re not doomed yet!’: All the dark clouds and silver linings on the climate crisis, explained
We might be in the grips of environmental crisis, but there are still things we can do about it
by: Gwynne Dyer
22 Apr 2024
Share
Though we are undeniably in the grips of a climate crisis, there are some reasons to retain hope for a better future.
The bad news
1. Emissions are bad
Greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) from human sources are the main problem. We are dumping 40 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide and other GHG into the atmosphere each year. That has raised average global temperatures by about +0.2°C per decade over the past 40 years. Recently warming has reached +0.3°C per decade.
It doesn’t sound like much, but you should think about global temperature like you think about your own body’s. At 36.8°C you feel fine, at 39°C you are running a fever, and at 43°C you’re dead. The Earth System is equally sensitive.
The ‘never-exceed’ temperature after which very bad things start to happen, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, is +2.0°C. Average global temperature in the past year has been a record high of +1.6°C. That’s well beyond normal climate variability. It could be a feedback …
2. Feedbacks are worse
We can track and predict the warming we cause ourselves. However, the new heat we have caused will also trigger various natural processes that warm the planet. For example, our heat is melting sea ice and snow cover on land in the Arctic. That snow and ice used to reflect incoming sunlight into space, but open water and bare rock absorb the sun’s heat – which is why the Arctic is warming four times faster than the rest of the planet.
That’s a ‘feedback’, and we couldn’t turn it off even if we stopped our emissions now.
Advertisement
Advertisement
There are about a dozen potential feedbacks. Most are probably lurking somewhere beyond +2.0°C – but not necessarily far above that average global temperature, and some could even activate before then.
The problem is mostly political
Gwynne Dyer
3. We are running out of road
We are not cutting our emissions and we never have. ‘Renewables’ are barely keeping up with the growth of coal, oil and natural gas. Fossil fuels still account for 82% of global energy production. The renewables – hydro, nuclear, wind, solar and geothermal – only account for 18%.
The problem is mostly political. Most of the countries that got rich by starting to burn fossil fuels long ago have now stabilised their emissions, although at a very high level. The other three-quarters of the world’s population – China, India, Brazil and the rest – want to be rich too, and they’re not willing to wait any longer.
That’s where the huge growth in new emissions is happening. Fossil fuels are still the cheapest way to get rich, and we can’t force the global south to stay poor. So we either subsidise them to build non-fossil energy sources instead, or we all live with the consequent global warming.
4. The crisis may be right now
The extraordinary climate events of the past year – the sudden upward lurch in global average temperature and the attendant wildfires, heat waves, floods and storms – far exceed what the scientists’ climate models predicted. Their predictions have usually been right, but now they lag far behind the reality.
Maybe it’s just random events, but we may have triggered some unexpected feedback. For example, some scientists suspect that our recent successes in cleaning up the ‘brown clouds’ that used to sit over big Asian cities and cutting sulphur dioxide emissions from 60,000 giant merchant vessels mean that more sunlight is reaching the surface and causing more warming.
Wind and solar energy have grown very fast in the developed world, but they can’t take over the whole job of generating power because they fluctuate. Sometimes wind doesn’t blow, and every night it gets dark. So the best news on the energy supply front is that geothermal power, using very hot rock (200°C-400°C) to generate steam and drive turbines, is no longer confined to volcanic areas.
There’s hot rock almost everywhere if you drill down three or four kilometres, and fracking techniques can be used to get high-pressure steam from those rocks to generate power 24/7. The first megawatt-range geothermal pilot plant is going operational in Nevada right now.
Solar power will also become reliable 24/7 once they build massive solar arrays in high Earth orbits, but that will have to wait for Elon Musk’s ‘Starship’ to deliver on his promise of a cost-to-orbit price of less than $200 (£158) per kilo.
2. Carbon dioxide removal
We are bound to overshoot both our ‘aspirational target’ of 1.5°C higher global temperature (in fact, we’re there right now) and our ‘never exceed’ limit of +2.0°C. Even if we could just stop the temperature where it is right now, all the ice on the planet would eventually melt and the sea level would rise by 70 metres, so we will need to get the temperature back down. In the long run, that means we will have to take at least half a trillion tonnes of CO2 out of the air.
Happily, the very first megatonne-range machines for removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere are being built right now. The full job may take as little as a century or two, and the annual cost would be about the same as all of the world’s defence budgets.
Advertisement
3. Precision fermentation
As the climate gets hotter and wilder, we’re going to lose a lot of cropland to floods, droughts and intense heat. Our population is still rising, so there may not be enough for everybody to eat. We are also losing biodiversity, mainly because we have taken over most of the world’s land to grow our crops, and the only remedy is to give a lot of that land back to nature.
What we need is ‘food from the sky’: food that does not require precious land to grow on. Luckily for us, such food is now becoming available. It’s called ‘precision fermentation’: carefully chosen microbes grown in bioreactors with water, hydrogen, carbon dioxide and light, doubling their mass every three hours. Drain the soup off once in a while, dry it, and you have a powder containing 65% protein (or carbs, or fat) that can be turned into any kind of food you want.
It can be turned into perfectly acceptable food for human beings, but the first priority will be animal feed. Half of all our farmland is used to grow feed for cattle. Feed them food ‘from the sky’ instead, and you can start rewilding a lot of that land and still have plenty of food for people and animals alike.
Global cooling
Cutting emissions is far harder both politically and technically than people thought, and the ‘never exceed’ +2.0°C average global temperature will probably arrive by the mid-2030s. We really don’t want to go there, but we need more time to get our emissions down.
We know at least two ways of holding the temperature down temporarily that would probably work and are neither very risky or too expensive. One is putting sulphur dioxide into the stratosphere to reflect some incoming sunlight. (Volcanic eruptions have already road-tested this technique for us.) The other is to spray an ultra-fine mist of seawater up into low-lying clouds to thicken them up and achieve the same result.
For many years various zealots have blocked any outdoor research on these techniques, but it needs to happen now. Ending GHG emissions is still the main goal, but if we can’t hold the heat down in the meantime, global order will collapse and we’ll never get there.
This article is taken from The Big Issue magazine, which exists to give homeless, long-term unemployed and marginalised people the opportunity to earn an income. To support our work buy a copy!
If you cannot reach your local vendor, you can still click HERE to subscribe to The Big Issue today or give a gift subscription to a friend or family member. You can also purchase one-off issues from The Big Issue Shop or The Big Issue app, available now from the App Store or Google Play
This Christmas, 3.8 million people across the UK will be facing extreme poverty. Thousands of those struggling will turn to selling the Big Issue as a vital source of income - they need your support to earn and lift themselves out of poverty.
