Advertisement
Opinion

Get your tax straight: two readers discuss the economy

Readers disagree on the function of tax and the question of what has gone wrong in our country’s coffers

A letter in issue 1550 titled ‘A taxing situation’ suggests that the primary function of tax is not to fund government spending… Unfortunately, this suggestion is wrong.

It embraced the fallacy of modern monetary theory, a largely discredited economic theory not supported by most economists. The UK government can only afford to spend so much without raising taxation (and to raise serious levels of extra revenue taxes must be raised on ordinary people, not just the rich, since there are far more ordinary people to tax compared to rich people in the UK).

If a government does not raise enough money in taxes then it must borrow money from the bond markets. In recent years central banks have made this easier by having very low interest rates and by printing money (quantitative easing) but this, for various reasons, has now started to create inflation in the economy. 

One of the classic textbook side effects of a government borrowing too much to fund itself is, eventually, inflation. If we want to help poorer people then somebody has to pay more tax, and there’s no point just saying you can get it all from the rich.

Yes, the rich could pay a bit more but ordinary people on average incomes will also have to stump up. And that is when things get politically difficult. Britain has an ageing society and so that is why our public spending is not going as far as it used to, this is a structural problem that will last for quite a while yet. 

Kyle in The City, London

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertisement

Kyle in The City is peddling the economic myth that an ageing society results in public spending increases and less income for the government.

Look how many retired people pay tax and how little funding there is for the NHS. The majority of our ageing population invested and saved for their retirement needs also while paying mortgages; the fact that governments have squandered those savings on, for example nuclear weapons, is now the cause of any imbalances of funds.

And to counter Terry Gibbs in Issue 1553, there is every reason to blame Maggie Thatcher for she sold off the ‘family silver’. Just look at the profits Centrica, formerly British Gas, is making that could and should be going into public coffers. Where did all the revenue from the North Sea oil bonanza go?

Answer: tax breaks for the rich. While we have a government that puts profits before society’s needs, our society remains in a mess and while the gullible fall for the Tory rhetoric… ditto. 

Malcolm Searle, Bury St Edmunds 

Do you have an opinion to share about this topic? Join in the conversation – we want to hear from you. And we want to share your views with more people. Get in touch and tell us more.

Your support changes lives. Find out how you can help us help more people by signing up for a subscription

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

READER-SUPPORTED SINCE 1991

Reader-supported journalism that doesn’t just report problems, it helps solve them.

Recommended for you

Read All
The Employment Rights Bill promises landmark reform. Will lack of foresight let it down?
Keir Starmer speaking in the House of Commons. Image: House of Commons/ Flickr
Emma McClelland

The Employment Rights Bill promises landmark reform. Will lack of foresight let it down?

Labour won't reduce homelessness until they understand how it links to immigration
homeless tents
Louisa Thomas

Labour won't reduce homelessness until they understand how it links to immigration

Laughter, songs and joy: This is how it felt the moment news of a ceasefire reached Gaza
A little girl amid the rubble in Gaza.
Mohammed Aklouk 

Laughter, songs and joy: This is how it felt the moment news of a ceasefire reached Gaza

Alison McGovern: 'Homelessness crisis is a reminder of how politics can fail people. It cannot continue'
homelessness minister Alison McGovern
Alison McGovern

Alison McGovern: 'Homelessness crisis is a reminder of how politics can fail people. It cannot continue'

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Cost of living payments: Where to get help in 2025 now the scheme is over
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Cost of living payments: Where to get help in 2025 now the scheme is over

Citroën Ami: the tiny electric vehicle driving change with The Big Issue
4.

Citroën Ami: the tiny electric vehicle driving change with The Big Issue