Let’s scrap the Vagrancy Act and help rough sleepers, not criminalise them

This week I am leading a debate in Parliament on helping rough sleepers by repealing and replacing the Vagrancy Act.

I’m proud that this government has an ambition to end rough sleeping for good. If we are to succeed, we need to scrap the Vagrancy Act. I recently asked a question to Communities Secretary Robert Jenrick about this and was delighted when he said the Act “should be consigned to history’”. 

The problem with the Act is that rather than seeking to help those on the street it criminalises them. Similarly, powers under the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act (2014), including Public Space Protection Orders and Criminal Behaviour Orders, are increasingly used to specifically target people sleeping rough, particularly those involved in anti-social behaviour.

Yes, we must challenge such behaviour, but rather than criminalise those involved, the better outcome for the individual and for society is surely to address the reasons why they are on the street in the first place?

Today in the House, I asked @RobertJenrick for a meeting to discuss the repeal of the #VagrancyAct while highlighting @CityWestminster's excellent work supporting rough sleepers off our streets. Watch his response �G pic.twitter.com/ho3L1F9GPY

— Nickie Aiken MP for Cities of London & Westminster (@twocitiesnickie) February 25, 2021

The Government’s ‘Everyone In’ strategy in response to the Covid-19 pandemic saw an incredible 90 per cent of rough sleepers accept accommodation, demonstrating that when central and local government work together we can achieve impressive results.

But what about the other 10 per cent?

Throughout the first lockdown Westminster continued to see around 100 people refuse help and remain on the street. I saw many of them and they were clearly very ill with serious addiction and mental health problems.

Having witnessed what I did and having spoken to former rough sleepers, outreach workers and other experts it is clear that if we are to end rough sleeping for good then a fundamental shake up of mental health services is required.

Even on the coldest day of the year, and during adverse weather conditions brought by the likes of the Beast from the East in 2018, a considerable number of people choose to ignore the no questions asked help of a hot meal and a roof over their heads – whether in local authority accommodation, a church, a community centre or a mosque. They are so fearful, mistrusting or often mentally unwell that they prefer to remain outside in below zero temperatures.

If we get this right, it will end the revolving door that too many rough sleepers currently experience

We need to replace the Vagrancy Act with laws that take a more assertive outreach approach. We need to offer greater social care and specialist medical support alongside the safety of a bed. That includes an addiction councillor, the psychiatric help, and the medical support for those who have suffered after years of sleeping rough.

There are currently around 400 beds available each night in Westminster for rough sleepers. However, those beds rarely come with the vital health services required to turn a person’s life around and address often years and decades of abuse and addiction. 

Charities, including The Passage, Crisis and St Mungo’s have highlighted that outreach workers today find it near impossible to secure mental health assessments for rough sleepers. We know that many on the street have complex needs. Some do not have the mental health capacity to make decisions for their own well-being or to accept the help on offer. If this approach is to work, we need to overhaul the mental health threshold. We need to allow outreach workers, working in partnership with specialist homelessness mental health teams, to undertake assessments on the street and make the decision on their behalf. We need rapid access to specialist bed spaces and the required health services attached to that bed.

Tomorrow, I'm going to be leading a debate in Westminster Hall on repealing and replacing the #VagrancyAct. Do you agree with me that the Act should be replaced? Let me know below ⬇https://t.co/Zx0Vrh7MeE

— Nickie Aiken MP for Cities of London & Westminster (@twocitiesnickie) April 12, 2021

At present a rough sleeper’s mental state has to become so acute – to the point that he or she is self-harming, or at risk of doing so, and the police need to take emergency action – before they can have a mental health assessment. By that stage it is far too late, which is why we need an assertive outreach approach. 

And we must back it up with long term, sustainable funding. Local authorities and charities need to know Government funding for such services will be for at least three years rather than the current annual basis. 

If we get this right, it will end the revolving door that too many rough sleepers currently experience whereby they accept outreach help, are placed in a hostel and eventually into their own accommodation – but too often find themselves back on the streets because their underlying mental health or addictions have not been tackled.

The Government is obviously willing and able to end rough sleeping. Repealing and replacing the Vagrancy Act, longer term funding attaching health services to accommodation, and re-establishing street-based mental health services will do that very thing.

Nickie Aiken is the Conservative MP for Cities of London and Westminster