Advertisement
Employment

Naming, shaming and failing: Punishments for firms paying below minimum wage have little impact

Consumers always favour cheaper prices over ethical concerns, according to new research into companies that flout employment rules.

Fines for companies who pay workers less than minimum wage aren’t steep enough to be a deterrent and publicly shaming them has little impact, research has found.

A three-year study by think tank the Resolution Foundation found consumers “always favour cheaper prices over ethical concerns” – leading experts to call on the government to do more than “name and shame” firms who exploit their workers.

The study estimates that a company found to be paying workers under the minimum wage would need to be fined around 700 per cent of arrears (overdue wage payments) to counteract the savings the company made in docking pay.

This is more than three times the maximum penalty of 200 per cent that HMRC can currently issue.

“Fines are too low so there is little economic incentive for rule-breaking employers to change their ways,” said Hannah Slaughter, economist at the Resolution Foundation.

“As well as raising the profile of the ‘naming and shaming’ regime, the government must introduce tougher financial penalties and more widespread enforcement to ensure that rule-breaking firms are caught and deterred,” she continued.

Advertisement
Advertisement

The Low Pay Commission and Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) names and shames employers who have failed to pay all of their employees at least the minimum wage

Household names including John Lewis, The Body Shop and Sheffield United Football Club were named, shamed and fined this year. 

But the shame levied on John Lewis didn’t last long, explains Slaughter, because businesses with big brand names are somewhat protected from reputational damage as customers “have already decided what they are like as a brand”.

Worse still, only one-in-five of the firms interviewed had heard of the policy, limiting its use as a deterrent. 

“Naming dodgy firms only works when they are caught in the first place, so more widespread enforcement is needed,” Slaughter continued. 

“There’s far more people being underpaid the minimum wage, for example, than are being flagged up on this naming and shaming list.”

While smaller businesses were found to be more likely to break the rules – minimum wage workers in micro-businesses are 37 per cent more likely to be paid below the minimum wage compared to those in the largest businesses – they are less likely to get caught and named for doing so, according to the research. 

Unpaid overtime is one way businesses “systematically chip away at people’s rights in an effort to cut costs,” says Dr Dora-Olivia Vicol, director of the Work Rights Centre. 

Known as ‘wage theft’ this practice can push those earning minimum wage below the legal threshold. 

For example, a person under the age of 23 earning a salary of £18,000 would be receiving the national minimum wage if they worked their contracted 35 hours per week. But once this creeps up to 40 hours per week an increase in pay, their hourly rate would fall below minimum wage.

“It’s been a difficult year for a lot of businesses, but that’s no reason to take from workers,” Vicol continued. 

To force companies to comply with labour market rules, the Resolution Foundation is calling for a strengthening of the profile of the existing ‘naming and shaming’ policy, rigorous enforcement of the rules, and tougher financial penalties for rule-breaking. 

Advertisement

Support the Big Issue

For over 30 years, the Big Issue has been committed to ending poverty in the UK. In 2024, our work is needed more than ever. Find out how you can support the Big Issue today.
Vendor martin Hawes

Recommended for you

Read All
'It's an epidemic': 1.4 million workers trapped in insecure jobs are stuck in precarious rented homes
insecure work and insecure rented homes impact life decisions
Employment

'It's an epidemic': 1.4 million workers trapped in insecure jobs are stuck in precarious rented homes

Millions of Brits think their jobs are 'meaningless.' Could a four-day working work week fix that?
Four-day working week

Millions of Brits think their jobs are 'meaningless.' Could a four-day working work week fix that?

'What are we going to do?': Misery for commuters as train strikes continue
Train strikes

'What are we going to do?': Misery for commuters as train strikes continue

British farmers demand universal basic income to prevent bankruptcy in wake of Brexit
Farmer mental health
Universal Basic Income

British farmers demand universal basic income to prevent bankruptcy in wake of Brexit

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over

Citroën Ami: the tiny electric vehicle driving change with The Big Issue
4.

Citroën Ami: the tiny electric vehicle driving change with The Big Issue