No, Gen Z don’t want the UK to be ruled by a dictator

Now is not the time to exaggerate the appeal of dictators or muddy what a dictatorship actually means.  

President Trump told voters he wanted to act like a dictator “only on day one”, but by day 26 declared “he who saves his country does not violate any law”. Trump called president Zelensky a dictator, with Elon Musk adding “despised”, despite rising approval ratings for the democratically-elected Ukrainian leader. 

With that backdrop, the claim that more than half of Gen Z Brits want the UK to be a dictatorship, based on a recent Channel 4 study, would be extremely worrying, if it was a true reflection of their views. It suggests a coming tide of sympathy for authoritarianism among our youngest generation and a bleak future for democracy.  

But there are reasons to be very sceptical this is really what Gen Z thinks.  

The study actually asked 13- to 27-year-olds whether they agreed “the UK would be a better place if a strong leader was in charge who does not have to bother with parliament and elections.” In their findings and press release, Channel 4 didn’t suggest that this equated to support for a dictatorship – but just about every news and comment piece that picked up the study did.  

• Reform UK’s climate denialism could devastate the very towns and cities they want to represent
• Robert De Niro and the Zero Day dilemma: Is Netflix scared of Trump?
• How do you kiss a Tory? Here’s what your political beliefs mean for your sex life

It might seem like a very justifiable interpretation – but we wanted to check, so we ran our own test in a survey of 1,000 13- to 27-year-olds. We simply replaced the wording “strong leader” with “dictator” – and instead of 52%, found only 22% agree with that version.  

That still leaves a worryingly large minority of Gen Z who seem to be supporting an extreme form of autocratic government. We tested that view further by asking those who agreed whether that meant they wanted no control or checks on the leader from MPs in parliament and no national elections at all. When these implications are spelled out, around half say no, actually, we would like some control and elections.  

When you work it all through, only 6% of Gen Zreally support a dictatorship, in any recognised sense of the term. The problem is not a whole generation of autocratic young people, but a complex question answered quickly in online polls and hugely over-interpreted in its reporting.  

And the fact that this interpretation was picked up so widely really is a problem, in at least three ways.  

First, it adds to sense of generational division, and particularly our willingness to believe that the current generation of young are the worst ever. It’s a deep human trait for older people to think ill of the young, and it’s been supercharged for us today by social media and media environments where generational labels have become helpful shorthand for spreading stereotypes and division. 

Second, there is a risk that this type of attention-grabbing discussion encourages a sense that this is in fact the norm among the generation themselves. A lot of media coverage of one poll doesn’t mean the line it pushes will become immediately true among that generation, but we know perceptions of what the norm is for our group can have powerful effects on our own views and behaviours. 

If we have concerns about Gen Z’s connection to liberal democracy, we should be extra careful not to spread an exaggerated negative view. 

Which leads to the third problem – that the noise around this distracts us from real and serious issues with Gen Z’s engagement with UK political systems and institutions. We risk labelling a whole generation as “authoritarian” when the real problem is a lack of confidence in the delivery of democratic institutions and systems. 

Our analysis of the World Values Survey, a major academic study that has tracked attitudes to democracy since 1981, shows that our younger generation’s problem is not with the principle of democracy, but its delivery. Gen Z are the least likely to think we even currently live in a democracy, which is perhaps understandable when so many policy decisions – from pensions and housing to support for the costs of education and childcare – have favoured older generations. 

We face a serious challenge convincing Gen Z that democracy and our political institutions can work for them – but exaggerating their desire to rip it all up doesn’t increase the sense of urgency, it just adds to the drama of generational division and risks giving a false sense of momentum to the decline of democracy. We have enough to worry about without that.  

Professor Bobby Duffy is the director of The Policy Institute at King’s College London.

Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more. Big Issue exists to give homeless and marginalised people the opportunity to earn an income. To support our work buy a copy of the magazine or get the app from the App Store or Google Play.