Scotland’s move to abolish poverty by ending two-child benefit cap must inspire Westminster

Last week, the Scottish government outshone the Labour government by committing to mitigate the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) two-child limit on benefits. This was followed by a request to meet the secretary of state before Christmas to ensure their promise becomes a reality. The poverty-inducing two-child benefit limit, restricting support to families since 2017, has impacted one in nine children across the UK with thousands falling into poverty since July’s election. More detail is needed, but there’s a script in place which could finally relegate this pernicious rule to history books.

Campaigners are adamant – abandoning this policy should have been the first action taken by the new Labour government to lift 300,000 children out of poverty. Not planning to eradicate it within the fast-developing UK child poverty strategy would be unthinkable. Scottish finance secretary Shona Robison’s announcement last week, which will put 15,000 children out of poverty in Scotland, looks set to encourage the UK government over the line.

But there’s more to be learnt from Scotland and its government’s laudable efforts to diminish the impact of austerity. As DWP ministers heard at the recent child poverty taskforce summit in Glasgow last month, efforts to bring down poverty rates are making a difference. The Scottish Child Payment (SCP) now means low-income families are eligible to receive £26.70 per child under 16 every week in addition to qualifying social security payments. Early evidence tells us that this strategy is working. University of Oxford’s Danny Dorling has predicted that because of this ‘cash first’ intervention, Scotland will transform itself to be one of the most equal countries in Europe.

And the Scottish government is the first in the world to develop and put into action a plan towards ending the need for food banks. DWP officials looking to realise Labour’s commitment to end mass dependence on emergency food parcels can find a strategy in place in Scotland. This plan prioritises a cash first or income-focused approach to food insecurity empowering local communities to drive forward change while helping to embed advice and support to maximise income as the first port of call for people facing financial crisis.

On top of the undertaking on the two-child benefit limit in last week’s draft Scottish budget, commitments to invest in affordable housing, free bus travel for asylum seekers, free school meal provision for children in receipt of the SCP, and an end to free school meal debt for this year stood out.

However, the Scottish government can and must do more to the turn of the tide of poverty in Scotland. More than one in five Scots are living in poverty including one in four children. Scottish ministers cannot be held back by the intransigence of Westminster. Yes, there are limits to devolved powers but there are more options at their disposal that could cut poverty rates.

• Two-child benefit cap to be scrapped in Scotland as Labour challenged to ‘step up’ and follow suit
• Homelessness set to soar by a third in Scotland in two years – but it ‘doesn’t need to be this way’

The Scottish Child Payment should be raised further to £40 as soon as possible, the adequacy of disability assistance payments must be addressed, and steps should be taken towards a Minimum Income Guarantee in Scotland. Free school meal eligibility needs to be extended to all children living in low-income families and the concept of free school meal debt eliminated for good.

Local advice and support services need critical investment, and the not so recent review of the Scottish Welfare Fund must result in concrete actions to increase the value of payments, raise awareness of this vital crisis support mechanism, and make help easier to access and administer. It’s also vital that there’s an amnesty on public sector debts impacting low-income families. And, of course, adequate wages and secure employment need to become the norm.

After years of consultation the Scottish Human Rights Bill has been “effectively ditched” by the Scottish government. This week, campaigners in Scotland are calling for the bill to be brought back to the table so that public authorities can be held accountable for human rights failures resulting in a million people living in poverty in Scotland. 14% of Scots are food insecure, the the right to food could provide the framework to reverse this for good.

It’s changes to the tax system in Scotland which could enable these vital transformations. Last month, in an open letter to the Scottish parliament party leaders, civil society organisations called for a fairer tax system pointing out that: “The Scottish parliament has wide ranging powers over devolved taxation and full powers over local taxation.” The newly launched Tax Justice Scotland calls for a fairer taxation system to ensure better living standards and reduce economic inequality in Scotland.

Defying Westminster on the two-child benefit limit has made welcome headlines but let’s hope this leads to yet more steps in the right direction in Scotland as well as the rest of the UK. Let’s hope that Scottish government can dig deeper to lift more people out of poverty. And let’s hope that by the time the Scottish government is ready to put their mitigation payments in place in 2026, a two-child limit doesn’t exist at all. After all, there is no excuse for any government to let poverty blight the lives of children or adults alike. Everyone should be able to access a living income and a healthy standard of living for all.

Sabine Goodwin is director of the Independent Food Aid Network (IFAN).

Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more. This Christmas, you can make a lasting change on a vendor’s life. Buy a magazine from your local vendor in the street every week. If you can’t reach them, buy a Vendor Support Kit.